For much of the summer, the militia stood guard, but by September the men had gone home. And that was the state of play one day when Rebecca (21) and Abby (15) Bates, daughters of Scituate Light lighthouse keeper Simeon Bates, observed a British ship making directly for the harbor. It seemed that the fears of the residents had come true, but no one was ready to repel the landing force.
With their father away, the Bates girls dispatched their brother to run for help. Then they came up with a plan. As the British ship drew near and began offloading sailors onto barges, the two struck up their fife and drum. Hidden from sight, the two girls sounded for all the world like an approaching army force.
Suddenly, the idea of harassing the boats in Scituate or coming ashore to cause even more damage didn’t seem so appealing. The sailors returned to their ship and departed, leaving a relieved town of Scituate.
Over the years, some questioned the facts of the story, but the Bates sisters never varied from their version of events, and later in life they took to retelling it and providing affidavits attesting to its accuracy.
And over the years, the story has been retold in children’s literature, including an 1874 issue of St. Nicholas Magazine for Boys and Girls and several books.